Suzi's Blog

Cookbook Review: Seriously Bitter Sweet by Alice Medrich

This is about an author and a book and why, if you enjoy chocolate, you want to have Seriously Bitter Sweet in your kitchen.

In 2003 chocolate maven Alice Medrich wrote Bittersweet, a primer on chocolate that reflected her 30 years of chocolate experience. Author, chef, chocolate shop owner, consultant to chocolate firms, Alice possessed all the knowledge needed to write a book for the ages.

Except even in 2003 Alice sensed the growing chocolate revolution that was about to explode worldwide and most specifically here in the United States. She knew that Bittersweet would need a successor, and now we have it. [Yes, it was Bittersweet then but Bitter Sweet now. Things change.]

Into the 70’s and 80’s in the United States there was baking chocolate and eating chocolate. “No sense wasting good chocolate in cooking” was a motto followed by many. And the baking chocolates came from one manufacturer primarily in colored boxes labeled unsweetened, bittersweet and semisweet. As you may have discovered, there really was no taste or cooking consequence for substituting between bittersweet and semisweet.

Then Alice went to Paris. That is a place where people know how to cook. She ate a chocolate truffle. Then another. Her year of graduate studies over, she returned to Berkeley to finish her masters degree. Along the way, sort of for fun, sort of out of truffle withdrawl, she began making truffles and other chocolate delicacies based on her European experiences. School dissolved in a mound of melted chocolate. She opened a famed store, Cocolat. She got orders from Zabars. She got a Gail Greene review. Her life was sealed in chocolate.

After Cocolat was sold, Alice consulted with the team at Scharfen Berger, the first bean-to-bar American firm in 50 years and the first ever to produce a 70% cocoa bar. And that was the rub, because she discovered that those high percentage cocoa chocolates — American or European — cannot just be substituted for the 54-59% style of recipes we had all gotten used to. With those boxes of cooking chocolate.

Bittersweet in 2003 began with an explanation of the coming tidal transformation and the possible consumer confusion as new chocolate makers came on line but rarely published the cocoa content on their packaging. Those percentages were considered a trade secret. As a consequence, many of us baked some chocolate extravaganza and had disappointments — because we had a complete mismatch in what chocolate we should have been using.

A decade has passed since Bittersweet and Alice has worked this entire time on educating people to work in this new land of chocolates. Packaging thankfully now helps because you can go into any gourmet, or even local, market and find shelves and shelves of artisan chocolates. The percentages are there on every competing label.

That’s where Seriously Bitter Sweet is your new chocolate bible. Alice has refined her earlier Bittersweet recipes to reflect the new percentage information that is available to you on each chocolate source. She tells you what percentage to use in what recipes and why. She’s learned herself how the new high percentage chocolates require adjustments to all the ingredients: less sugar and less cream and less egg — not more — are needed to expand out the more complex flavors of the new artisan chocolates. For example, she prepares crème brulee with water not cream and she knows why it is better.

Alice is proud to state that Seriously Bitter Sweet is the only book on the market that addresses this chemically complex issue, that educates you, and that gives you an array of both sweet and savory chocolate recipes tuned for perfection.

The American food scene is, thankfully, abundant with artisans of all shapes and sizes. Boutique gin and bourbon producers can be found in old warehouses in Brooklyn or on faraway farms in upstate New York. The story holds across the country.

And artisan chocolate makers, real bean-to-bar producers, are sprouting up everywhere, too. In our upstate town of Olive, we have Fruition Chocolate just three miles away. It’s conveniently located between our pizza/barbecue hangout, the gas station, and the post office. You can’t go anywhere for anything and not pass Fruition, so you might as well …

Fruition is an example of the outstanding new chocolates. But, after our first bites, Suzen and I had the same question: with something this intense and rich, how do we cook with it? Seriously Bitter Sweet is our guide, and yours, to enriching your life in the new chocolate environment. You could not have a better instructor than Alice Medrich.

Flourless Chocolate Cake


wc 2 IMG_5744

Some food items are simply hard to photograph. Soup. Drinks. Flourless chocolate cake.

The taste of this cake is exceptional but photographing it is hard. The side is one solid slab of darkness. No grain or texture. Just a mass of dark something. This could probably double as part of a set on a science fiction film.

Except, this is no fiction. It’s a real cake, a real recipe. Both molten and flourless chocolate cake recipes abound. Sometimes, you can be a bit confused about what you are eating: is this kinda molten or flourless kinda? Here, there is no question. No molten anything. Deep, dark and dense.

Overpoweringly dense. I actually recommend that you not eat this by itself. The flavor is so overpowering, that a complement is needed. Unsweetened whipped cream — yes, whipped perhaps with a little vanilla but no sugar — is the perfect foil, and that follows in the recipe below.

Or vanilla ice cream. Better, French vanilla.

Or, a glass of port or brandy.

Just something to offset the relentless dense chocolate intensity. Hey, I’m not complaining here. I love this dessert, but everyone has their limits and this certainly pushed mine.

A heavy meal, say steaks off the grill, can often demand an equally intense dessert so that there is no “meal letdown.” You scale up your wine complexity during your meal. Dessert often follows the same pattern. If “light and delicate” won’t do, then it is time for the heavy artillery. This cake is just what you meal demands. There will be no complaints but quite possibly a few “Oh my Gods.”

The official name for this recipe is Chocolate Cracked Earth. Do not be concerned. It’s a massive creature and the thermal stress in your oven is going to create cracks. See, I told you this belonged in a science fiction film.


Chocolate Cracked Earth (aka Flourless Chocolate Cake)

Yield: serves 10


  • ·       1 pound bittersweet chocolate, chopped into small pieces
  • ·       1 stick unsalted butter*
  • ·       9 large eggs, separated
  • ·       ¾ cup granulated sugar, plus 1 tablespoon
  • ·       2 cups heavy cream, cold
  • ·       Confectioners’ sugar, for dusting


Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Butter a 9-inch spring form pan.

Put the chocolate and butter into the top of a double boiler (or in a heat proof bowl) and heat over (but not touching) about 1-inch of simmering water until melted. Meanwhile, whisk the egg yolks with the sugar in a mixing bowl until light yellow in color. Whisk a little of the chocolate mixture into the egg yolk mixture to temper the eggs – this will keep the eggs from scrambling from the heat of the chocolate; then whisk in the rest of the chocolate mixture.

Beat the egg whites in a mixing bowl until stiff peaks form and fold into the chocolate mixture. Pour into the prepared pan and bake until the cake is set, the top starts to crack and a toothpick inserted into the cake comes out with moist crumbs clinging to it, 20 to 25 minutes. Let stand 10 minutes, then remove sides of pan.

While the cake is cooking, make the whipped cream. Whip the cream until it becomes light and fluffy.

Serve at room temperature dusted with confectioners’ and the whipped cream.

Source: Tyler Florence on

Photo Credits: Canon T2i, 18-55MM Macro lens, F/5.6, 1/10th second, ISO 3200